Negative gearing gets political again!

 

It’s hard to believe this topic is still giving people nightmares. And yet, here we are. Accountants underestimated the complexity of this thing. As usual, we don’t empathise with “civilians”. So, negative gearing remains a hot topic for property investors. It impacts taxes, cash flow, and housing markets. In recent years, updates have shaped how owners use this tool. A property tax accountant can help investors stay informed and avoid costly mistakes. This article will explore negative gearing, its rules, recent updates, and how it affects residential property owners.

What is Negative Gearing?

Negative gearing occurs when rental costs are higher than rental income. That sounds simple enough at first. The shortfall can reduce taxable income. This means landlords pay less tax. Many investors use this strategy to grow wealth.

For example, if a property earns $20,000 in rent but costs $25,000, the $5,000 shortfall is a loss. This loss offsets other taxable income.

Why Do People Use Negative Gearing?

Many landlords choose negative gearing to lower tax bills. This strategy can also help with long-term property growth. Owners may accept short-term losses to build wealth later.

The main benefits include:

• Lower Tax Bills: Reducing taxable income saves money.
• Capital Growth: Over time, property values may rise.
• Cash Flow Management: The tax offset can ease financial strain.

A property tax accountant ensures investors follow tax rules. They also help calculate losses and tax savings.

Recent Changes to Negative Gearing

There have been rather heated discussions about changing negative gearing rules. It’s getting political, fast. Some groups argue it drives up home prices. Others say it helps middle-income investors build wealth. Recent years have seen few big changes, but it remains under review.

Proposed Limits to Negative Gearing

In 2019, the Labor Party suggested major changes to negative gearing. They planned to limit the strategy to new properties only. Older homes would no longer qualify. This proposal aimed to:

• Lower home prices
• Help first-time buyers enter the market
• Shift investment focus to new builds

These changes did not happen. The government kept the current rules. Investors can still claim losses on old and new properties. Some argued that this would drive the price of new houses up. Because there isn’t enough tradies. And if the benefit is only available to new ones, then the same number of tradies now have to build more. Demand and Supply. Prices go up for new ones & drop on older ones.

Either way, the topic remains active with accusations of “rorts” flying back and forth from both camps! Tax reviews could revisit this plan. Investors should stay updated with a property tax accountant.

Impact of Rising Interest Rates

Interest rates have surged in recent years. Higher rates increase borrowing costs. This affects negative gearing directly.

When mortgage payments rise, so do property costs. This can create larger losses for negatively geared homes. For many landlords, this means bigger tax offsets. But it also strains cash flow.

For example:

• A loan cost $15,000 a year when rates were low.
• Now, the same loan costs $22,000.
• If rent stays the same, losses grow by $7,000.

Investors may struggle to keep up with higher payments. A good accountant may also suggest ways to ease the impact..

Tax Office Crackdown on Claims

The Australian Taxation Office (ATO) has tightened its focus on property claims. Incorrect or inflated deductions are a concern. Negative gearing claims are a major target.

The ATO has found many landlords make errors in their tax returns. Common mistakes include:

• Claiming repairs as capital works
• Misreporting rental income
• Overstating interest deductions

Inaccurate claims can lead to audits and penalties. A tax accountant ensures compliance. They help landlords maximize their claims without breaking rules.

Negative Gearing and Property Values

Negative gearing impacts housing markets. Some experts say it pushes prices higher. This happens because investors compete with homebuyers.

For example:

• A family may bid $500,000 for a home.
• An investor, attracted by tax benefits, bids $550,000.
• The investor wins, and home prices rise.

Critics argue this locks out first-time buyers. Others say it drives growth in new housing. Recent updates have not removed negative gearing. But the debate continues.

Negative Gearing and Rental Markets

Negative gearing affects renters as well. Many landlords rely on tax savings to hold their properties. Without these savings, they might sell their homes. This could lower rental supply.

When rental supply drops, rents often rise. Tenants would pay more for fewer homes. Some experts argue that negative gearing helps keep rents steady.

A property accountant can explain how this works. They can also help landlords decide if negative gearing fits their plans.

How Negative Gearing Helps Middle-Income Investors

Negative gearing is often linked to high-income earners. But many middle-income earners use it too. A 2022 report found that most negatively geared investors earn under $100,000.

For these investors, tax savings help offset short-term costs. Over time, they hope for capital growth. Negative gearing allows them to build wealth while managing losses.

For example:

• A teacher buys a rental property.
• Rent does not cover the mortgage and other costs.
• The teacher claims the loss as a tax deduction.
• In 10 years, the property value grows.

With careful planning, middle-income investors can benefit.

Risks of Negative Gearing

While negative gearing offers benefits, it carries risks. Investors should understand these before relying on it.

Cash Flow Problems: Negative gearing requires ongoing losses. Investors must manage these losses without financial strain.

Rising Interest Rates: Higher borrowing costs can increase losses. If rents do not rise, investors face tighter cash flow.

Falling Property Values: Negative gearing works best when home prices grow. If values drop, investors lose money and tax benefits.

Positive Gearing as an Alternative

Some investors prefer positive gearing. Positive gearing occurs when rental income is higher than costs. This creates a profit instead of a loss.

Benefits of positive gearing include:

• Steady cash flow
• Less reliance on tax deductions
• Lower financial risk

For example:

• A home earns $25,000 a year in rent.
• Costs total $20,000.
• The investor earns a $5,000 profit.

Positive gearing does not rely on tax breaks. But it may result in higher taxable income. A property tax accountant can help compare these strategies.

Negative Gearing vs. Positive Gearing

Here’s a quick breakdown of the differences:

Factor	Negative Gearing	Positive Gearing
Cash Flow	Negative (short-term loss)	Positive (short-term profit)
Tax Impact	Reduces taxable income	Increases taxable income
Financial Risk	Higher risk with rising costs	Lower risk due to positive cash flow
Capital Growth	Depends on property value increasing	Can still benefit from growth

Both strategies have their place. A property tax accountant can help investors choose the right one.

How to Stay Updated on Negative Gearing

The rules around negative gearing can change. While no major updates have happened recently, the topic stays active in policy talks.

Here are ways to stay informed:

• Follow Budget Announcements: Government budgets often include tax changes.
• Work with Experts: A property tax accountant can keep you updated.
• Monitor the ATO: The tax office publishes rules and updates online.

By staying informed, investors can plan for changes and avoid surprises.

Conclusion

Negative gearing remains a powerful tool for property investors. It helps offset rental losses and reduce taxable income. While recent updates have not removed negative gearing, the debate continues.

Rising interest rates and ATO crackdowns have added new challenges. Investors must manage cash flow and follow tax rules carefully.

Both risks and rewards come with negative gearing. Middle-income investors benefit most when planning is done right. With expert advice, they can manage costs and build wealth for the future.

For now, negative gearing rules remain the same. But staying informed is key. Future updates could bring changes.

 

This article is clearly for general information purposes only. It does not constitute financial or tax advice. Always consult a qualified property tax accountant or financial advisor for guidance tailored to your personal circumstances. Tax laws and property regulations may change over time. You need to stay updated. The author and publisher do not take responsibility for decisions made based on this content. For professional advice, please seek assistance from a registered expert.

 

Or call us on 1 800 672 670

Works Cited

Australian Taxation Office. “Rental Properties 2023.” ATO, 2023, www.ato.gov.au/general/property/rental-properties.

Property Council of Australia. “Negative Gearing and Housing Supply.” Property Council of Australia, 2022, www.propertycouncil.com.au.

Real Estate Institute of Australia. “Impact of Negative Gearing on Property Investment.” REIA, 2023, www.reia.com.au.